Last Friday
whilst it was slowly sinking in that we had actually voted to leave and it
wasn't a bad dream, I decided that I would write down my thoughts and feelings
on the event. This was for 2 reasons really, one was that I had so many
thoughts and emotions running through my head that I felt it would help to make
them slightly more coherent if I wrote them down. The second was to keep a
record from my own personal view to look back on over the years. I wanted to
wait a few days so that this wouldn't end up as some bitter rant and also to
try and get an idea of what I think is going (or not) to happen. I’ll explain
why I voted to remain, why I think Leave won and also what I think the future
will hold. I think enough has been said about the disgusting xenophobic
incidents we are currently seeing throughout the UK so I’m going to steer clear
of that as much as possible.
Why I voted Remain
I have always
considered myself to be on the left, I would even dare to say a socialist,
although that appears to be a very dirty word in today's world. I believe that
in a truly civilised society everyone should have access to free education,
free health care and should be free to live their life regardless of race,
sexuality and religion. The EU had
always been a bit of a conundrum for me, during the lead up to the
referendum I was constantly being told that as a “lefty” I should be
instinctively opposed to an organization such as the EU. However, although I
can understand that point of view I never really felt that way. I have always
thought that becoming more integrated with the rest of Europe was the way
forward and I have always had very little time for the “little islander”
attitude that has always been prevalent in the UK. True, the EU is a
bureaucratic monster that clearly puts commercial interests ahead of social
ones, but is that any different from any country in the world?
How would my
life have turned out if I had never been a citizen of the EU? This is the
question I used to decide my vote.
Bit of
background, I am from a small town in the English peak district, a beautiful
town but deathly boring and not many job opportunities so eventually I found
myself in London. Whilst in London 2 events occurred that would never have
happened if it wasn’t for the freedoms we have from being part of the EU. The
first involved my brother who also made the treacherous journey down south to
London. He was working as a hair dresser and like most young people was getting
increasingly fed up with most of his wage packet going on rent for some damp
infested shit hole. So one day he decided that he’d had enough, he packed his
bag bought a plane ticket to Berlin (no he’s not an aspiring techno DJ) and he
left. He's now fluent in German and is loving living in a city that can be
enjoyed even if you aren’t a millionaire. The second event was that whilst I
was working in a south London hospital I met a girl who I am now engaged to,
she is from Madrid and like many Spaniards her age found herself having to move
to find work. Fast forward 3 years and we are now living in Spain preparing for
our wedding next month. Had it not been for the freedom of movement that having
an EU passport grants you, it is highly unlikely that I would be sat here in
Spain typing this. Freedom of movement is one of the core principles of the EU
and it is something that we should be thankful for. I was recently chatting to
a friend who is from Latin America and lives in London, she was saying how we
are in for a shock when we realise how difficult, time consuming and expensive
applying for Visas can be. I’ll explain later why I don’t think this will
happen but just the very thought of it was enough for me to be a strong
“remainer”.
Other reasons
for my Remain vote were my refusal to believe the lies that all the problems of
the UK were the fault of immigrants, and even with my limited economic
knowledge I could see that as the world is teetering on another recession,
placing our own economy into a period of chaos however short it may be, wasn’t
wise. I am currently several thousand
euros poorer thanks to the value of my savings in sterling falling off a cliff!
And I am sure many fellow Brits who live within the EU are in the same boat.
I’ll get the
sovereignty issue later on, but the idea of an “ever increasing” political
union didn’t really worry me, in fact I always thought that the more
politically integrated we became the larger the say we would have in who is in
the European parliament. Instead of voting for a national parliament we could
have voted for a European one. Sadly, I think as a race we are still too
preoccupied with the issue of nationality and we still think that the patch of
earth we were born on somehow makes us different from other people.
Why I think “Leave” won
The simplest answer for this is
that they campaigned better. As much as I loathe people like Farage and Boris
(and I really really do hate them), I have to grudgingly respect how they
positioned their campaign and completely out manoeuvred the Remain crew. I do
talk about immigration but you can skip to the next paragraph if you’re sick of
hearing about it.
Regardless of what the victorious
leave voters say now about immigration not being the issue for them in an
attempt to distance themselves from the predictable xenophobic events we now
see on our streets in 2016 (although you could easily be mistaken and think you
were in the 30’s), immigration was a huge factor in the decision. There are a
sizeable number of people in the UK (as with any country) who simply don’t like
foreigners. The problem is when the global economy isn’t doing well the ruling
elite impose austerity on us and then through the media tell us it’s our own
fault. The next obvious target to blame is “foreigners”, we have seen this
throughout history and we are currently seeing it in Europe now. Austria nearly
elected a fascist as president, the National Front are gaining ground in France
and we have UKIP. All of these parties were nowhere to be seen at the turn of
the century when the good times were rolling. Farage himself hit the nail on
the head the other day with “when I first came here, stated my intention to
lead a campaign to take Britain out of the EU you all laughed at me”. He was
right, we did, because at the time it seemed like a joke, the problem is people
continued to laugh at him until last Friday morning when they suddenly realised
how dangerous he was. Take a browse
through the right wing media (which is pretty much all media) of Britain over
the years and you will see headline after headline of anti-immigrant sentiment.
But, that said, to brand every Leave voter as a racist is both lazy and untrue.
Yes, there was an element of that in the Remain vote, that is undeniable,
however, many Leave voters did not vote to go because of immigration and this
is where Remain really fucked it up.
The Leave mob played the absolute
master stroke of turning the campaign into “the Establishment” versus “the
People”. This really was genius and is why they won. By continuing to refer to
the EU as either “the establishment” or “the elite” and constantly pointing out
how they put commercial interests before those of the people “just look at what
they did to Greece”, the Leave campaign created the illusion that they were
fighting for the rights of the forgotten working class. What made matters worse
is that leading the Remain campaign was the Prime Minister and the Chancellor,
how much more “establishment” can you get? And then heading up Leave you had
Nigel “he calls a spade a spade” Farage and everyone’s favourite buffoon Boris
Johnson. By regularly trotting out pearls such as “let’s spend that cash we
send to Brussels on the NHS” and “our grandparents fought for our right to
decide our own laws” they spoke right to the heart of the nation! Christ, if
their claim about pumping an extra 350m into the NHS a week was legally binding
even I would have voted Leave.
Where the Remain campaign dropped
the ball is that they failed to point out (or at least they didn’t do it well
enough) that our Boris and Nigel are also part of that elite that they are
slagging off. As much they portray themselves as the “blokes down the pub” they
are both public school boys who are stinking rich and have both previously
expressed the view that the NHS needs to be privatised. The Remain campaign
should have been screaming this from the rooftops but instead they focused on
how most Leave voters were poorly educated and from the north of England. By
calling somebody a thick northern racist you aren’t suddenly going to persuade
them to change their mind! Another idiotic move by the Remain campaign was the
constant doom saying about how we would lose access to the common market if we
left the EU. Most people neither know or give a shit what the common market is,
they want a school place for their kid or a Drs appointment when they need one.
To your average “thick northern racist” this sounded like “we bankers in the
city of London want to carry on making shit loads of cash so we need you
peasants to pipe down and vote Remain”. The Leave was retort was perfect,
“don’t worry, the Germans will still want to sell us cars”. Apart from being
probably true it spoke to people in a language they understood. While the
Remain campaign was continuing to focus on immigration and how everyone in
Leave was a horrid racist, the Leave team were slowly building the support of a
disgruntled and unrepresented working class.
What I think
will now happen
When the result came in I had a
moment of panic and had visions of the Guardia Civil kicking my door in,
wearing those weird plastic hats and dragging me to the nearest airport. The
day of the result we had a meeting with the judge regarding our wedding, would
that be all out of the window because we voted to leave the EU? Although I am
an “extranjero” in Spain, being an EU citizen is essentially the same as being
Spanish in terms of civil rights, if I was say American, the marriage process
would be even more complicated than it was. Once my initial panic had settled
down and I was assured that I would still be considered an EU citizen for the next
2 years, my panic turned to fury. Don’t worry I’m not going to go through the 5
stages of grief but my current mood is deep sadness. Sadness at how my country
is being perceived by my Spanish friends and family (and my brother’s German
friends), sadness at how being openly racist appears to be socially acceptable
on the streets of the UK and also I feel really sad for the people who voted to
leave because they genuinely believed it would improve their lives.
A friend of mine who voted to
leave told me his reason was “sick of those rich bankers in Brussels telling me
what to do” or something along those lines. Basically he fell hook line and
sinker for the “the people vs the elite” argument. When I asked him if a Tory
led government that had just broken away from the shackles of the EU would make
his life any better, he couldn’t really answer me. The argument that a vote for
leave was a vote to break away from an undemocratic institution that is making
our lives so difficult was an inviting one. The reality is that as workers we
have done very well from the EU, putting the opportunity to live and work in
several countries aside, working hours, holiday entitlement, maternity (and
paternity) leave have all come from being part of the EU. Our American cousins
would give their right arm and probably even their automatic assault rifles to
have the working rights we have. Although it may or may not happen, the fact is
that now the Tories could vote to remove or reduce any of those rights and we
have lost the protection that being part of the EU would have given us. The
bottom line is, as brilliantly put in an article in the FT is that we have
simply replaced one set of distant elite for another. Bankers will still make
millions and we will still be paying to drag our country out of the recession
they put us in whilst we are told it was our fault for daring to ask the bank
for a mortgage.
To not like being told what to do
is human nature but unfortunately unless you are one of those mythical elite,
I’m afraid it’s tough shit, you will still be told what to do by a government
that doesn’t want to spend money on the public services they told you would
improve if we left the EU. You will still have to enter a lottery to get your
kid a place in the local school, you’ll still have to wait for a GP
appointment, your train to work will still be delayed or if you drive/cycle to
work you will still have to travel on roads that look like Islamic State has
paid us a visit. This is because successive governments have failed to spend on
infrastructure or have sold it off to private businesses who only care about
that little number on the top right of the ticket for the train you are waiting
in pissing rain for. Whether any of these issues would have changed if we
remained in the EU is debatable but in my opinion they are far less likely to
now we have left.
Some of the more worrying aspects
of leaving the EU are what it may mean for the environment and also human
rights. The EU has an emissions target which although could have been a lot
stricter than it is, it is better than nothing at all. I know the environment
isn’t a particularly sexy topic and few things cause more eye rolling but I
still live in hope that we will do something before we have to start paying for
breathable air. Climate change aside the air quality in our largest cities,
especially London, is deteriorating fairly rapidly. What worries me is that on
the list of priorities of a post-EU British government, the environment is
going to be way down if it’s on there at all. The Tories have been dying to rid
themselves of the European charter of human rights for ages and although they
give the reason that they would be able to boot that Chowdry idiot out of the
country, personally I would rather have him in the UK than give up the
protection that the charter offers me. Maybe I’m being paranoid but it makes me
very uneasy when I hear my government talking about replacing a charter of human
rights with one of their own, it all sounds a little bit too totalitarian for
my liking.
adding to that PM hopeful Theresa May desperate trying to get the snoopers charter through parliament. Frightening!!
Where I don’t think there will be
much change is with the freedom of movement, which was one of the main issues
for me.
Although I may have got this completely wrong
my understanding is as follows:
- · The core principles of the EU free market are the freedom of movement of, people, goods, services and capital
- · There is also the European Economic Area that consists of the EU plus non-EU countries, Norway, Iceland, Liechtenstein
- · Switzerland has not joined either EU or EEA but has trade agreements with both to allow access to the free market
- · The EEA and Switzerland have to adhere to the 4 core principles in order to be part of the free market
- · Therefore, ALL countries have to allow the freedom of movement of people.
- · They still have to contribute financially to the EU but not as much and they receive no funding in return
So once we formally leave the EU
we will have several options.
The first being the most unlikely is that we
completely remove ourselves from the EU and the EEA. We would have complete
control over our borders and so on but it would put our status as being the
global financial centre at jeopardy. The reason London is currently the number
one is because we have access to the common market, if that were to change
there is the very real risk that banks, especially non-European ones, would
simply move their offices to an EU country which would mean job losses on top
of the negative economic effects. My friend who works for an American trust
company told me that the bosses have already made it very clear that if this
happens then it’s off to Ireland. Many people may be thinking who cares? But as
much we hate the financial industry, the fact remains that without it we
wouldn’t be one of the richest nations. This would be like the Germans suddenly
getting rid of BMW and then saying they were still the big boys when it came to
car manufacturing. Also you could add in to the mix that if option one were to
take effect then it would almost certainly mean the end of the UK as Scotland
have made it very clear that they intend to remain in the EU. So all in all
option one would be pretty unappealing for Boris.
The second option which is almost
as unlikely is that the UK manages to negotiate the freedom of goods etc. but
not people. Whilst this is not impossible it would require agreement from all EU
nations and I can’t imagine Italy and Spain etc. signing up to let the UK into
the free market whilst also denying their citizens the opportunity to go and
work there. Not to mention that Norway et al would be soon knocking on Brussels’s
door demanding the same deal. The knock on effect of that would basically
render the EU useless as it would prove you could pick and choose which bits of
the treaty you wanted, so I would be staggered if the UK could swing that one
no matter how many BMWs they promise to buy.
The third option which I think is
most likely is that very little changes, the UK wants to be in EEA and the EU
wants the UK in the EEA. The UK will have to accept the terms of entering into
the EEA and therefore the freedom of movement of people will remain. I
personally cannot wait to see buffoon Boris bumbling his way through that
speech when he has to explain that no we aren’t “sending the buggers back” and
although we have left the club we still want our nose in the EU trough but now
we have even less say about what rules apply in order to get it in there. The
UK may be able to restrict access to benefits for migrants but it won’t be able
to stop them coming. Which, if you are like me and believe every human should
have the opportunity to move to a more prosperous area to improve their lives
(as I did when I moved to London) will make you very happy. Whereas if you are
like the utter dregs of society that we are currently seeing on the news then
you won’t be too chuffed, but tough shit I’m afraid!!
So to cap it all off, once the
dust has settled people will realise that although a “foreigner” isn’t telling
them what to do, they are still being told what to do. The daily express will
still go through its headline cycle of “we’re all going to freeze to death in
winter – immigrants are stealing our jobs – princess Diana – immigrants again –
we’re all going to burn to death in summer”. And unfortunately the working
classes will once again realise that the government doesn’t have their best
interests at heart. Maybe one day they’ll stop voting for right wing
governments!
The only thing that will have
changed is that finally Boris will have managed to outmanoeuvre his old Eaton
chum and will become leader of the Tories which if anything shows the lengths
that the man will go to for power.
What a colossal waste of time!!!
At the point of finishing this I noticed
that that weasel Gove has stabbed his Brexit chum in the back and tossed his
hat into the ring for Tory leadership. So now you have the choice of him, buffoon
Boris or Theresa May who has been trying to pass a bill that would allow the
government to snoop through your phone and email data. What a terrifying thought,
thank ‘effing Christ I decided to leave!
